Keep annotations when I download routes FORUMS HOME SEARCH FORUMS

Total posts in this topic: 17
Showing oldest posts first - Show newest
Sign in to post to this topicSIGN IN

    Page: 
    • 1
  • Photo
    Julien Plotaroute   Tuesday 12 Aug 2025 09:25:08

    @Peter: Before sending it to the devs, I have just tried editing your route, and am now wondering if this is somehow the expected outcome.


    When downloading a route as GPX > Route > POI, it says "POI's = only directions with labels/symbols".
    If you add a label to your directions, the GPX file does include this information:

    "
    <rtept lat="59.367213" lon="18.074926">
    <ele>13</ele>
    <time>2025-08-12T00:12:50Z</time>
    <name>Test PO</name>
    <cmt>{Stora Skuggans Väg</cmt>
    <desc>{Stora Skuggans Väg</desc>
    <sym>Parking Area</sym>
    </rtept>
    "

    However, I don't have any route information.
    The Route feature adds a waypoint for every direction and is meant for devices which calculate their own route between waypoints.
    But the POI's feature adds a waypoint only if there is a symbol or tag.
    I'm wondering if the POI's option somehow counteracts the Route option.

    Have you used this download setting before?
    Did you use to get both waypoints for directions and waypoints for directions with labels?

    Thanks for your help!

  • Photo
    Peter Höglund   Tuesday 12 Aug 2025 20:23:09

    Ok, then I understand how it's supposed to work, and it behaves the same for me.

    Two things make this a little confusing.

    • When downloading GPX>Tracks>POI's, then POI refers to the Annotations and they are made to Waypoints in the file. When chosing GPX>Tracks>Dirn's the directions are converted to Waypoints.
      When downloading GPX>Route>POI's, then POI refers to the Directions IF they have a symbol.
    •  I couldn't see the instruction "POIs = only directions with labels/symbols", but after a while I found it when you download from VIEWing the route. If you download while editing the route, there is no such text.

     

  • Photo
    Peter Höglund   Tuesday 12 Aug 2025 20:41:46

    I didn't use the GPX>Route download, I understand now.

    I tested again, and it still works. At least with my Garmin Epix watch.

    1. Create a route with both a route and Annotations.
    2. Download the route with the options GPX>Track>POI.
    3. Copy the file from the laptop to the Garmin/NewFiles folder on the watch.
    4. On the watch, all annotations get a flag as a symbol.
    5. On the watch, I can:
    • Navigate to the Annotations/Waypoints/POI, but on my watch, I find them under the menu 'Saved Locations' or 'Locations'.
    • Change the symbol or name after selecting a Saved Location.
    • See all Saved Locations on the map regardless of which route/course I'm following. This can be toggled off in the Activity settings>Map layers>User locations.

     

  • Photo
    Julien Plotaroute   Wednesday 13 Aug 2025 08:43:36

    Hi Peter!

    Thanks for your step-by-step instructions on Garmin. :)
    I'll copy the link to this topic, in case this question comes up again.
    @Ian: I hope this helps and applies to your Garmin device as well.

    I just checked out the download screens, and there are several differences:
    The first difference is between Web app/mobile site and Desktop site.
    When using the desktop version, you can hover/tap on "POI's", for example, and a tooltip will provide more information. This is the case for a lot of buttons on Plotaroute.
    This doesn't apply to the web app and the mobile version. 
    From "Viewing the route", the download screen is the same on the Web app/mobile site and the desktop site.
    However, from "Editing the route", the download screen is different from the "Viewing the route" download screen and also the screen doesn't appear to be the same on the Web app/mobile site and the desktop site.
    So, depending on what device you are using and on which page you're on when downloading, the screen is quite different.
    This is no doubt something that can be improved.

    Now, I wanted to truly understand all the outcomes of the situations you mentioned, and have created a test route and added two things:
    I used "Annotate map" to add a car park next to the route (with a label).
    I edited a direction and added a label (also did the test without adding the label).

    GPX + Track + POI's = route + car park as waypoint and the direction as waypoint (only if I add a label to the direction)
    This seems slightly wrong, as the tooltip says "Track points for the whole route with optional waypoints for directions" (for Track) and "Add Waypoints to the file for every direction that has a symbol or label" (for POI's)
    If only directions with a label or symbol were added as waypoint, then the car park shouldn't be added as a waypoint.
    The fact that the direction only shows up as waypoint when I add a label is in line with the tooltip information.
    Maybe the tooltip should say "Add waypoints to the file for directions and annotations with a label or symbol"

    GPX + Track + Directions = route + car park as waypoint and the direction as waypoint (no matter if I add a label to the direction or not)
    This also seems slightly wrong, as the tooltip says "Add Waypoints to the file for every direction" (for Directions)
    The fact that the direction gets added as waypoint, regardless of the label is normal and in line with the tooltip information.
    But the car park isn't a direction.
    Maybe the tooltip should say "Add Waypoints to the file for every direction and annotation"

    GPX + Route + POI = a single point: the direction I changed, if I add the label
    This is a bit strange, but I guess it's the normal outcome, because "Route" is "Just the waypoints (directions), but "POI's" needs the directions to have a label.
    Maybe it could be clearer if the tooltip for "Route" said "Just the POI's or Directions - for devices with route calculation capabilities"

    Does this all sound correct, and would those changes to the tooltip make things clearer as to what result you'll get?
    If so, I can ask the devs if this is something they'd consider changing.

    All the best,
    Julien

     

     

  • Photo
    Peter Höglund   Wednesday 13 Aug 2025 21:43:13

    Ok, yes, and there is one other small but annoying difference between the view and edit download. In the view route, the download options are 'remembered' (maybe by device cookie). In Edit download, they are not, not at least the shift back directions that I set all the time to 15m (one of your unique features).

    To compare your results with mine:

    • GPX + Track + POI's, I get the same result as you if I add a label. That was a finding, and I also think it is quite confusing. The thing is that I never use labels on directions. Only use it if it's a fit file up-ahead.
    • GPX + Track + Directions, I get the same result as you. Directions and Annotations were also added as Waypoints for me. (edited after 2 min)
    • GPX + Route + POI, Same as you. Directions with labels become Route Points in the file. There are no Waypoints in your GPX route files.
    • GPX + Route + Dir, All directions become route points, with or without labels. There are no Waypoints in your GPX route files.

    My suggestion is not to use the POI word in your descriptions. Only use what you have in your toolbox:

    • Annotations
    • Directions with labels
    • Directions w/o labels

     

  • Photo
    Julien Plotaroute   Thursday 14 Aug 2025 05:50:16

    Thanks, Peter!

    I'll send those findings to the devs and hope that this is something that can be implemented to improve and clarify the download process.

    All the best,
    Julien

  • Photo
    Topic
    Creator
    Ian Sherman   Friday 15 Aug 2025 14:49:32

    Thank you all so much, I am so very grateful for the advice and the step by step instructions.

    I think I wasn't using the GPX>Track>POI option, rather Route>POI/Directions

    Now when I download it as GPX>Track>POI the annotations are visible on my Garmin (Edge1000), albeit very small and limited to 10 characters (although this may be a Garmin issue).

    A definite improvement though and thanks so much to everyone for your help, which is sincerely appreciated 

    Ian

     

Page: 
  • 1